Failed approach · scope boundary

MRF-058

Treating RPR-D11 as the simultaneous BCLR baseline after Run 12

Exact statement

Treating RPR-D11 as the simultaneous BCLR baseline after Run 12. RPR-D12 has a verified common-DAG receipt and substantially lowers additions, scalar gates, fan-out, and copy count. RPR-D11 remains preferable in raw dependency depth, one scalar of declared storage, and rounded-path length.

Statusrejected.
External reviewNo documented external or specialist review of the FPRD synthesis is recorded.

Context

The research record preserves failed approaches when they expose a model boundary, an invalid transfer, or an unsupported strengthening.

Proof or evidence

RPR-D12 has a verified common-DAG receipt and substantially lowers additions, scalar gates, fan-out, and copy count. RPR-D11 remains preferable in raw dependency depth, one scalar of declared storage, and rounded-path length.

Verification notes

The failure status and preserved lesson are recorded in the cumulative failure ledger.

Limitations

  • retain the Pareto set; do not silently select one realization or merge their best coordinates.

Open work

Keep this exclusion attached to any future reuse of the corresponding construction.