Theorem · classical extremal transfer and sharp boundary

FPRD-SH-T22

Uniform zero-overhead policies obey the Kneser stability trichotomy

Exact statement

For a one-support-per-letter policy with support family F⊆([n]r)\mathcal F\subseteq\binom{[n]}r, universal zero overhead is equivalent to F\mathcal F being independent in KGn,rKG_{n,r}. If n<2rn<2r, every support family has zero overhead. If n≥2rn\geq2r, then ∣F∣≤(n−1r−1)|\mathcal F|\leq\binom{n-1}{r-1}; for n>2rn>2r, equality requires a full star. When r≥2r\geq2, n>2rn>2r, and the core is empty, the sharp Hilton–Milner ceiling is (n−1r−1)−(n−r−1r−1)+1\binom{n-1}{r-1}-\binom{n-r-1}{r-1}+1. At n=2rn=2r, maximum families choose one support from each complementary pair, and empty-core examples exist for r≥2r\geq2.

StatusExact automata reduction with classical EKR and Hilton–Milner inputs; equality cases audited
External reviewNo documented external or specialist review of these FPRD results is recorded.

Context

The universal zero-overhead policy criterion becomes an independence problem in the Kneser graph when every letter has one support of the same size.

Proof or evidence

FPRD-SH-T14 supplies the exact automata reduction. The case n<2r is immediate because no two r-sets are disjoint; EKR gives the ceiling from n=2r onward, and Hilton–Milner gives the exact empty-core ceiling for r>=2 and n>2r.

Verification notes

Complete small domains cover 1,082,432 support families. At (n,r)=(7,3), all 175 maximum empty-core families are exactly the classical 140 Hilton–Milner and 35 three-set exceptional families.

Limitations

  • The extremal set theorems are classical; only their automata interpretation is FPRD work.
  • The theorem assumes one support per letter and a uniform support size; the Hilton–Milner clause requires r>=2 and n>2r.
  • Universal zero overhead does not imply that every disjoint-support policy has overhead for every expression tuple; it supplies an exact one-shot witness.

Open work

Use FPRD-SH-T23 for the quantitative receipt once the EKR ceiling is crossed.