Definition attempt · strengthened construction discipline

FPRD-RE-D02

Carrier-free constructor-only quotient compiler

Exact statement

A carrier-free constructor-only quotient compiler recurses on ordinary regular-expression constructors and returns an ordinary regular expression, without enumerating a residual carrier, saturating a finite relation, or adding an explicit least-fixed-point constructor.

StatusInformal exclusion-based discipline; a formal compiler class is still missing
External reviewNo documented external or specialist review of this FPRD result is recorded.

Context

The proved finite-derivative algorithm and the stricter presentation discipline are different questions. This record names the intended restriction, but does not yet define a mathematical class of compilers over which existence or impossibility can be quantified.

Hypotheses and scope

  • The output syntax uses the ordinary empty, epsilon, letter, union, concatenation, and star constructors.
  • Residual enumeration, relation saturation, and an explicit least-fixed-point operator are excluded from the compiler interface.

Proof or evidence

The record pins a deliberately strict editorial discipline. It does not claim that every reasonable meaning of ‘purely inductive’ must satisfy these restrictions.

Verification notes

Review found that exclusions such as ‘do not enumerate a carrier’ can be disguised extensionally unless the allowed recursion schemes, auxiliary data, and cost model are formalized. The record is therefore not treated as a completed definition.

Limitations

  • The definition may be narrower than other legitimate syntax-directed algorithms.
  • No grammar of admissible compiler clauses, auxiliary operations, or extensional equivalence has been fixed.
  • It does not itself establish existence or impossibility.

Open work

Specify an admissible compiler grammar, auxiliary-state policy, and equivalence/cost model before testing general existence or impossibility.