persistent-nilpotence no-go verification critical algebra basis: 1, e, e^2 rank over the parameter base: 3 x^3(1+t*x) and x^3 define the same completed local ideal: unit factor e^3 = 0 and e^2 != 0: PASS Hessian determinant j = 3e^2 is nonzero nilpotent: PASS Norm(j) = det(multiplication by j) = 0: PASS Trace-pairing discriminant = 0: PASS Reduced support of every fiber is one point: follows from rad(e^3)=(e) Pairwise Poisson commutativity of separated Hamiltonians: PASS Conclusion: finite-flat persistent nilpotence and Liouville integrability do not force a positive-dimensional critical locus in a fiber.